Fact-Checkers Trace Gaza Snake Video

· OSINT

TLDR

  • Lead Stories says Hive Moderation and Sightengine scored the clip as likely AI-generated, but readings varied between frames.1
  • Rumor Scanner traced a version to a 12 March Facebook comedy post; Lead Stories found an 11 April TikTok copy.14
  • i24NEWS says Tayqan found nothing placing the scene in Gaza; it adds the woman speaks Hindi.3

Fact-checkers say a 14-second clip shared in November as showing Israel dropping snakes on Gaza is AI-generated and had been online for months with no link to Gaza.123

Why it matters: detector scores swung widely in this case. Lead Stories reports readings from 0.1 per cent (Hive Moderation) to 99 per cent (Sightengine) across the same clip, and NDTV Profit says the detection results were combined with visual inconsistencies and earlier versions of the video.12 Dated earlier uploads, including a 12 March original and an identical 18 June copy, show the clip predates the Gaza claim by months.34

Driving the news:

  • The claim: Lead Stories says the claim appeared in an X post on 11 November saying Palestinians were sharing that Israel was dropping snakes on Gaza.1 i24NEWS says the clip had passed 200,000 likes on TikTok.3
  • The detection: Lead Stories says Hive Moderation gave an averaged 70.4 per cent likelihood of AI generation and 98.2 per cent for the speech, while Sightengine showed 99 per cent at the 13-second mark and as low as 1 per cent at other moments.1 NDTV Profit says Tayqan, a Palestinian fact-checking platform, reported that a detection tool classed a sample of frames as likely AI-generated with a score of 99.2 per cent; i24NEWS gives the same score without naming the tool.23
  • The provenance: Rumor Scanner says the original version is a 12 March Facebook post from a page called Juvenildo Official, tagged as comedy, and that Hive Moderation rated it nearly 100 per cent likely to be AI-generated. Rumor Scanner's 10 August article shows the footage was already being passed off as a Gujarat event.4 Lead Stories found a TikTok copy posted on 11 April and an Instagram copy posted on 4 September by an account Instagram labels as AI-generated.1 i24NEWS says Tayqan found an identical version posted on 18 June with a Hindi caption.3

The big picture: Lead Stories says several variations of the theme are circulating, some that appear to show the same dusty corral with water buffalo and a different woman running while filming.1 i24NEWS says the woman in the clip speaks Hindi and the animals resemble water buffalo, which it says suggest the scene imitates a rural Indian setting, and that some shapes move sideways through the air while falling.3

The other side: Lead Stories says the detection tools disagreed with themselves across the clip, with Hive Moderation reading only 0.1 per cent at the three-second mark. NDTV Profit says its conclusion also drew on visual inconsistencies and earlier versions of the video.2

Single-source note: Tayqan's own report was not found, so its findings are as relayed by i24NEWS and NDTV Profit. NDTV Profit and i24NEWS may share that one origin, so they are not treated as independent. Rumor Scanner's article was read directly, in Bengali. The videos were not viewed, and the detector scores are outputs of commercial tools.

Sources

  1. Fact Check: FAKE Video Shows Snakes Raining From Sky, It Is AI-Generated (Lead Stories)
  2. Snakes Falling From The Sky In Gaza? Viral Videos Trigger Buzz Online; Here's The Truth (NDTV Profit)
  3. Une Vidéo TikTok Accuse Israël De Larguer Des Serpents Sur Gaza (i24NEWS)
  4. গুজরাটে আকাশ থেকে সাপ পড়ার দৃশ্য দাবিতে এআই ভিডিও প্রচার (AI video claimed to show snakes falling from the sky in Gujarat) (Rumor Scanner)