Fact-Checkers Flag Doctored Kulgam Video
TLDR
- Four Indian fact-checkers say the clip pairs a March 2025 The Wire interview with altered audio; three say AI.1234
- Factly, Newschecker and Alt News say the speaker is Sushant Singh, not ex-Army officer Pravin Sawhney.134
- Newschecker says Hive Moderation rated the speech 98 per cent likely AI-generated; Singh publicly called the clip fabricated.34
Four Indian fact-checking outlets say a video shared after an 11 November attack on a CRPF checkpoint in Kulgam, Jammu and Kashmir is a March 2025 interview with its audio altered.1234 Factly, Newschecker and Alt News say it was presented as a former Army officer calling the attack a "false flag" and that the audio was AI-made.134
Why it matters: the outlets say the fake borrowed a real, dated interview and a wrong name, and that reverse image search of keyframes led them to the original.123 Newschecker cites detector scores, and the interviewee has publicly denied the clip.34
Driving the news:
- The claim: Factly says terrorists reportedly opened fire on a CRPF checkpoint near Mir Bazar in Kulgam on 11 November, and ThePrint, carrying a PTI report, says three CRPF personnel were injured.15 Alt News says a clip posted on X on 12 November had a speaker named as retired Army officer Pravin Sawhney saying "Another false flag, just like Pulwama and Pahalgam", and that other X and Facebook users shared it.4 OnlyFact says accounts it describes as Pakistani shared it with captions about Indian voices questioning "false-flag" operations.2
- The trace: all four outlets trace the footage to a full interview on The Wire's YouTube channel from March 2025, and Factly, OnlyFact and Newschecker say reverse image search of keyframes led them there.123 Factly and Newschecker put the original about 20 months before the Kulgam attack.13 OnlyFact gives the upload date as 10 March 2025 and the title as "Six Years of Balakot: A Military Failure, But Political Success? | Samvad with Ashutosh", and says the video was published over a month before the April 2025 Pahalgam attack, confirming that the Pahalgam reference was fabricated.2 Alt News says the frames, including attire, background and lighting, are identical to the original, and that only the audio was changed.4
- The audio: Alt News says it saw lip-sync discrepancies and an unnatural, monotonous cadence in both voices.4 Newschecker says Hive Moderation gave a 98 per cent likelihood of AI-generated speech, Detect Video AI called the video "likely manipulated" at 59 per cent, and the Hiya Deepfake Voice Detector gave the audio an authenticity score of 2 out of 100.3 Factly says the tools it ran found the audio manipulated, without naming them.1
- The denial: Alt News, Factly and OnlyFact quote a post on X in which Singh calls it an "AI generated video of an old interview" that "completely fabricates my conversation" with the host, Ashutosh Bhardwaj, and calls it "Pakistan-made"; Factly and Alt News date the post 13 November.124 Newschecker says both men publicly clarified that the clip is AI-manipulated.3
The big picture: Alt News says the clip's lines refer to Balakot, Pahalgam and Operation Sindoor, and that the interviewer is heard asking whether testing the Pralay missile signals a new "false flag operation".4 OnlyFact says the clip was framed as "voices from within India" questioning official accounts.2 The fact-checkers do not say who made the audio; "Pakistan-made" is Singh's description, not a finding by the outlets.124
The other side: the detector readings vary widely in Newschecker's report, from 98 per cent AI speech to 59 per cent manipulation likelihood, so the finding rests on the dated original and the denials rather than on scores alone.3
Single-source note: the four fact-checks are separate write-ups but all rest on the same The Wire original and the same Singh post on X, neither of which was viewed here, nor was the circulating video. OnlyFact does not mention Kulgam or a former Army officer, and says only "fake audio" without naming AI. Detector outputs are as reported by Newschecker. Factly names no tool. The outlets describe Singh differently (Factly "journalist and author", OnlyFact "senior journalist", Alt News "columnist and strategic affairs expert", Newschecker a Yale lecturer in South Asian studies). Alt News says the original interview does not mention Balakot or any "false flag", while the other three tie it to the Balakot airstrikes, which matches the video's title as OnlyFact gives it; the difference has not been reconciled. The attack details come from Factly, Alt News and a PTI report on ThePrint, which this article did not check against a second wire report.
Sources
- AI-manipulated video shared as ex-army officer calling the Kulgam terror attack a false flag (FACTLY)
- Video of Ashutosh Bhardwaj and Sushant Singh Calling Pulwama, Pahalgam Attacks 'False-Flag' Is Digitally Altered (OnlyFact)
- Video Claiming To Show Ex-Army Officer Calling Kulgam Attack A False Flag Operation Is Doctored (Newschecker)
- 'False flag operations': Columnist Sushant Singh's video doctored with AI; Singh misidentified as Pravin Sawhney (Alt News)
- Terrorists fire at CRPF checkpost in Kashmir's Kulgam area, three injured (ThePrint (PTI))