North Korea Photos Likely Date To 2022
TLDR
- NK PRO says photos in North Korea's 4 November strike drill report likely date from November 2022.1
- NK PRO says one runway photo was blended with another, and a courtyard and building replaced with grass.1
- UPI says KCNA claimed a hit on a simulated airport; NK PRO says imagery makes confirming a test difficult.12
NK PRO, the subscriber service of NK News, reported on 13 November that photos Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) published on 5 November with its report on a 4 November "fire strike drill demonstration" of a "long-range strategic cruise missile" were not taken recently and likely date from November 2022.1
Why it matters: North Korean state media photos are hard to check on the ground, and NK PRO says North Korea has a long history of altering images of military events. Its analysis shows how dated commercial imagery can test a state media photo against the date it is said to show, using runway paint, stones beside a stream and Planet Labs imagery.1
Driving the news:
- The claim: UPI says KCNA reported on 5 November that a unit in the country's eastern region held a strike drill on 4 November with a long-range strategic cruise missile, which KCNA said successfully hit a simulated airport target.2 The Korea Herald, carrying Yonhap, says a firepower subunit of the long-range strategic cruise missile unit staged the drill against a "virtual airport target".3 NK PRO says KCNA published four photos: a Hwasal-series cruise missile shortly after launch, the missile flying low over a road, and an air base runway with 28 flat fighter jet-shaped targets in seven diagonal rows, covered in dozens of explosions and smoke plumes in the fourth photo.1
- The imagery: NK PRO says it identified the runway as Riwon Air Base on the east coast, north of Sinpho, by matching runway paint and surroundings with Google Earth imagery. It says Planet Labs medium-resolution imagery shows no sign of the 28 targets on the morning of 4 November, the next day or any day since 2022, while the 28 targets appeared on the runway between 6 and 8 November 2022 in the same positions and were removed between 9 and 12 November.1
- The tell: NK PRO says stones placed beside the runway in 2022 have since been used to build a raised path across a stream, and that path does not appear in the KCNA photo, which it takes as proof the photo is old. It says shadows suggest the photo was taken between 3 and 5 p.m. Korea Standard Time.1
- The alteration: NK PRO says the central runway area and the explosions in the fourth photo were artificially blended on top of an earlier photo. It also says a paved courtyard and at least one building at the far end of the cross-stream path appear to have been replaced with an empty grass field, probably to stop observers geolocating the air base, and that simple photo editing or artificial intelligence tools could have done it.1
The big picture: NK PRO says the photos were probably chosen because they were taken at the same time of year as the claimed test, so foliage looks right to a casual viewer, and that the 28 targets echo a March 2022 South Korean "elephant walk" of 28 F-35A jets.1 UPI and The Korea Herald describe the 4 November air defence test and strike drill as the fourth round of North Korean weapons tests in a week; both mention a "dispersal warhead" for a strategic cruise missile reported the previous Monday.23
The other side: NK PRO says there are no obvious signs of large impacts or explosions on the runway, but no commercially available high-resolution imagery exists for November 2022, so it is difficult to say whether a kinetic test on the targets took place. It says that if one did, it probably did not involve a new cluster warhead.1 NK PRO also says state media did not mention cluster warheads in its report on the 4 November test, and that the appearance of simultaneous strikes strongly suggested Pyongyang wanted observers to assume a second test of that kind of warhead. The NK PRO headline nonetheless calls the test faked.1 UPI and The Korea Herald report the KCNA account of the drill and do not address the photos.23
Single-source note: the photo analysis rests on NK PRO alone. The NK PRO article is paywalled, so its text was read from an aggregator copy, and its annotated comparison images were not viewed. UPI and The Korea Herald confirm only what KCNA claimed. UPI describes Kim Jong Sik, who it says oversaw the air defence test, as a member of the Central Military Commission, while NK PRO says state media named him, as a first vice director of the Party Munitions Industry Department, as overseeing the drill; the differing descriptions have not been reconciled. No second outlet has been found yet that independently dates the photos.