Satellite imagery access narrows for researchers

· OSINT

TLDR

  • Researcher Ollie Ballinger says US government pressure led private firms to restrict satellite imagery of the Middle East.1
  • Bellingcat found Sentinel imagery over Gaza and parts of the West Bank delayed 24 hours since 28 March.2
  • The European Commission confirmed restrictive measures on 5 November but did not say which territories they cover.4

Open source researchers are losing parts of the satellite record over the Middle East, from two directions. A New York Times Opinion video published on 11 November has Ballinger, an open source researcher and lecturer, arguing that US pressure on American imagery companies has produced a blackout, and Bellingcat reported on 29 October that the European Union's free Sentinel imagery over Gaza and parts of the West Bank is delayed by a day.12

Why it matters: a withheld or delayed image slows or blocks independent checks of claims made during a conflict. Bellingcat's example is Hebron: imagery from 26 October for the western half of the city, where demolitions had taken place, was not available until 27 October.2

Driving the news:

  • Commercial imagery: Reuters reported on 5 April that Planet Labs told customers it would indefinitely withhold imagery of Iran and the conflict region, saying the US government had asked all providers to do so, with imagery withheld back to 9 March and case by case release for urgent, mission critical or public interest needs. This expanded a 14 day delay imposed in March, which Al Jazeera says extended an initial 96 hour delay.35 Vantor told Reuters it had not been contacted by the US government and applies its own enhanced access controls in parts of the Middle East.3
  • Where it stands now: the New York Times says Planet Labs has partly lifted its restrictions across the Middle East, but that as of 1 November multiple companies, including Planet Labs and Vantor, were still restricting imagery over Gaza and southern Lebanon. It says the Defense Department and National Reconnaissance Office declined to answer questions about requests to restrict imagery.1
  • Europe's free data: Bellingcat says tile metadata shows an image of a tile covering Gaza captured at 08:20 UTC on 21 October was not published until 10:09 UTC on 22 October, almost 26 hours later, while a neighbouring tile was published just under four hours after capture. It says the Gaza tile has been delayed by a day consistently since 28 March 2026, and identifies four delayed regions: the Gulf of Oman, the Gulf of Aden and western Arabian Sea, the Red Sea, and the Eastern Mediterranean including Gaza.2
  • The EU response: an EU spokesperson told Bellingcat the delay was meant to "mitigate possible threats" arising from the war in the Middle East and was not related to events in Gaza, and that such decisions are taken unanimously by member states.2 Per AFP, the Commission confirmed on 5 November that it applies "restrictive measures" to the broadcasting of certain satellite images to protect European interests, without confirming the territories, and said such procedures are not made public unless the Council decides otherwise.4

The big picture: Bellingcat says a July Council decision (2026/1716) ordered a 24 hour delay over the Gulf of Oman after a US request, and was removed from the Council record by a corrigendum two weeks later, although satellite data shows the delay remained. It says Sentinel data had become a refuge for researchers as commercial providers restricted imagery, so a delay there matters more.2 Ballinger says the commercial blackouts cover much of the Gulf region, including places such as Gaza and Lebanon with no official US military presence, and that the House Intelligence Committee has asked the Pentagon and the director of national intelligence for a new plan to regulate satellite companies that do business with the government.1

The other side: the New York Times says there was concern from both the administration and members of Congress that commercial imagery had been used by Iran to target US troops. Planet Labs called the situation "extraordinary circumstances".13 Kevin O'Connell, a former director of the Office of Space Commerce, says in the video that governments will reserve the right to control imagery in a crisis, but questions the effect when competitors, specifically Chinese ones, supplied imagery of the same scenarios in short order.1 Vantor, per the New York Times, said it was following its own policies.1

Single-source note: the first item is an Opinion video, so its claims about US pressure are Ballinger's, and the New York Times page was read as a republished transcript, not the video itself. Planet Labs' April statement is relayed by Reuters and AFP, and the later status (partial lifting, restrictions on 1 November) is the New York Times' own statement, not a company statement read here. Bellingcat's tile analysis was not reproduced, and the Commission's confirmation reaches this article through AFP and a Romanian outlet, translated. No named US official has been quoted as requesting the restrictions.

Sources

  1. The View From Space the U.S. Government Doesn't Want You to See (The New York Times)
  2. EU Satellite Imagery Delayed Over Gaza and Parts of West Bank by 24-hours (Bellingcat)
  3. Satellite firm says it's indefinitely withholding Iran war images at US request (The Times of Israel (Reuters))
  4. CE limitează accesul la imaginile din satelit ale unor zone din Orientul Mijlociu. Cum explică decizia (Digi24 (AFP))
  5. US satellite firm Planet Labs announces blackout on war on Iran images (Al Jazeera (AFP, Reuters))