Storyful says viral bear video was real

· OSINT

TLDR

  • Storyful says a viral video of a bear on a power pole was authentic, though commenters called it AI.1
  • Storyful names shaky zooms, fur and grass texture, and occlusion as checks, then confirmed source, date and place.1
  • KOAT and USA Today reported the bear incident in New Mexico, USA Today dating it to Monday 20 July.23

Storyful published a walkthrough on 12 November of how its journalists showed that a video of a bear on top of a utility pole, dismissed by many commenters as AI, was real footage filmed in New Mexico on 20 July.1

Why it matters: wrongly labelling a real video as AI is the mirror image of missing a fake. Storyful's account shows the visual tells for AI video were only the start, and that the case rested on provenance: the original uploader, file metadata, a second angle and an official statement.1

Driving the news:

  • The claim: Storyful says the clip began circulating on X on 21 July through an account that regularly posts scraped footage, which said it was recorded in Arizona. Commenters said the bear could not balance on the pole and "would have been fried by now".1
  • Tracing the source: Storyful says it found an older version uploaded to Facebook on 20 July that appeared to be the original. The uploader confirmed recording it and allowed Storyful to distribute it. Storyful says it found the location was New Mexico, not Arizona, with photos the uploader posted a day earlier corroborating that they were there, and that the raw file's metadata showed the video was filmed on 20 July, the day it was uploaded.1
  • Corroboration: Storyful says it found a second video of the same scene from another angle, and that a New Mexico Department of Wildlife spokesman confirmed the incident in a statement to Storyful.1 KOAT reports the department was notified on a Monday morning of a bear on a power pole east of Gladstone, New Mexico, and that the bear sustained fatal injuries before the Union County Sheriff's Office arrived.2 USA Today reports video of the bear was captured on Monday 20 July in Union County and that the bear was electrocuted while trying to come down.3
  • The tells: Storyful says AI generators "for now" struggle to copy the imperfect way people film, with shaky hands, random zooms and subjects bouncing around the frame, and that AI user generated content tends to be "a bit too perfect". It adds that fine textures such as fur or grass can come out too smooth or uniform, and that generators handle occlusion poorly, giving the example of a tiger in a cage whose bars might take on the tiger's stripes.1
  • Applied to the clip: Storyful says the shaky zoom was the first sign of authenticity, followed by individual blades of grass, fur blowing in the wind, and the base of the pole remaining visible behind a wooden fence without the fence taking on the pole's characteristics.1

The big picture: Storyful concludes: "Just because one commenter has a hunch a video is AI, doesn't make it so." It says knowing the tells helps prove a video real as well as fake, and that used in tandem with open source verification methods and traditional reporting they can protect a newsroom.1

The other side: the tells are Storyful's own heuristics and it describes them as holding "for now", which suggests generators may close the gaps. Its account treats the visual cues as the start of the case, with the provenance steps following.1

Single-source note: the methodology, the metadata check and the contact with the uploader are Storyful's own account, which was not independently reproduced, and the video was not viewed here. KOAT and USA Today confirm the incident and place, and USA Today the date, but not Storyful's verification steps or tells. The USA Today page was read only in part. The private individuals who filmed or called in the incident are not named.

Sources

  1. Real or AI video? How Storyful verified a viral bear clip (Verified by Storyful) (Storyful)
  2. Bear dies after climbing on top of telephone pole in Clayton, New Mexico (KOAT)
  3. Bear stuck atop New Mexico power pole electrocuted (USA Today)